Round 1, Match 7: Shield of Stars vs. Saving Francesca

1_7Judged by Tori • Find her on Goodreads


After reading both these books, I was a little stumped on how I was going to judge them, given how different they are from each other. Shield of Stars by Hilari Bell is a fantasy novel, complete with kings, gods, and a plot to overthrow the government. Saving Francesca by Melina Marchetta tells a more ordinary – but no less compelling – story of a girl struggling through family turmoil.

Although very different, these two novels have more in common than first appears evident. Both deal with loss of belief and discovery of self, although the belief systems vary wildly.

Shield of Stars is the story of Weasel, caught up in a revolution against his will. When his benefactor and savior, Justice Hollis, is arrested and sentenced to death, Weasel undertakes a journey to save him. With the help of a fellow prisoner, a young girl named Arisa, the two of them journey into the countryside in search of the elusive bandit, the Falcon.

Weasel, born and bread in the city, and a common criminal making his living as a pickpocket before he was taken in by Hollis, doesn’t have a lot he believes in. Throughout the novel, Arisa attempts to get him to believe in something – the rebellion, the gods, her fortune telling ability. Throughout it all, Weasel staunchly maintains that his only motivation is saving Justice Hollis, that he doesn’t believe in any greater cause.

This claim is undermined on more than one occasion in the novel, notably when he balks at the idea of killing to achieve his goals, and when he and Arisa are conned by a fellow criminal. These instances prove his ability to believe in, and act for, more than just his own means. All of which climaxes with Weasel choosing to compromise, not only for his own sake and the safety of Justice Hollis (previously his primary motivator), but for the good of the Kingdom.

When Shield of Stars begins, Weasel sees himself as an entirely selfish and self motivated individual. Throughout his journey, he learns an appreciation of how other people in the kingdom live, their beliefs and what compels them. I’m eager to read the rest of the trilogy to find out how selfless of a character he might become.

Saving Francesca’s titular character follows an almost opposite journey. When the story kicks off, she’s very comfortably situated in her life. She has her friends (her “friends,” her mother would refer to them as), her family, her place in the world as she sees it is very much settled.

The novel opens with Francesca struggling to fit in at St. Sebastian’s, a boys’ school masquerading as co-ed. Fitting in to a school with only 30 girls seems like an insurmountable task, until the morning where Francesca’s mother doesn’t get out of bed.

As Francesca and her family struggle to cope with her mother’s depression, she starts to find a new place for herself in the world. A place where the people around her truly care about her instead of only pretending to. A place where she is cherished and loved, even when she is difficult – and she often is.

As I was reading I kept thinking to myself how Francesca was the kind of teenager – the kind of person, really – I wished I could be like. The kind who people flock to, the kind who holds everyone together, because that is what Francesca does throughout her story even when it’s hard, even when it doesn’t seem like it.

The budding relationship between herself and Will is charged and romantic (can I just say, Sophia Loren?). Her friendships are achingly real, and remind me of the women I have in my own life. Her family relationships are tough and sad.

My maternal grandmother suffered from mental illness. She passed away when I was in my early teens, before I had the chance to really understand what that meant. I think my mom did her best to shield myself and my siblings from her own tumultuous relationship with her mother. Mental illness is tough on everyone it touches, not just those who are themselves suffering. Francesca’s mother hovers like a specter over most of the book in a way that reminds me of my late grandmother. The way the ripples cascade out even now, more than a decade since her death.

The novel’s emotional climax had me in tears (I would suggest not reading this book at work like I did), and even just thinking about it now as I write this up has me a little choked up. A friend of mine described the novel as emotionally powerful, not only in how the book made her feel, but how it made her feel about herself. I couldn’t agree more, and for that reason I am selecting Saving Francesca to advance to the next round.


Congratulations to Saving Francesca, which moves on to Round 2!

Advertisements

19 thoughts on “Round 1, Match 7: Shield of Stars vs. Saving Francesca

  1. You guys are so not going to make my job as the Round Three Judge for this part of the bracket easy. But I couldn’t be more happy about that. 🙂

    Saving Francesca is a powerful book and I love it for all the reasons you mention. The friendship between the four girls is my favorite example of female friendship in YA literature. I adore Will. (Yes, Sophia Loren! And I think he’s so realistic in all his awkward, stumbling relationship mistakes.) Tom and Jimmy remind me so much of guys I hung out with in HS and they fit the girls so well. Then there’s Francesca and her dad-that’s the part of this book that makes me cry EVERY TIME. This is my favorite Marchetta novel, making me part of the minority who doesn’t think Jellicoe Road is the best. The companion to this is my 2nd favorite. (The Piper’s Son-read it too!)

  2. SO I gave this book to my friend and she called me to ask me what the line meant – “I hate the life that according to my mother, I’m not actually having” – AND ALL MY COHERENCE DESERTED ME. Someone help me string together words? It’s right in the beginning of Saving Francesca.

    1. Her mother wants her to have a certain kind of life and is upset that Francesca isn’t “living up to her potential” (probably) and she doesn’t want to be that person. That’s my take on it.

      Otherwise, I will say nothing more about this book until my round. 🙂

      1. Hahaha, I tried to explain it and it came out so convoluted. Her mother wants her to be a certain way! She isn’t that way because she doesn’t want to be that way! She doesn’t have that life but if she had it, she would hate it! It was a little dizzying.

        1. I think that line also is specifically tied into the school change. Her mother wants her to live a life that this school, this change of circumstance can give her. After the school change is made, she IS living that life, but only because she’s being forced to. And the being forced to is why she isn’t actually having it. I think.

  3. Oh Saving Francesca, such a good book. I love her group of friends. They are all so well written. But yeah, her relationship with her mom really got to me after awhile. I might have to re-read this book. It’s been awhile.

  4. Beginning to feel like I should try Marchetta. Not sure if this one is the one to start with, or another one though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s