Round 1, Match 3: The Goblin Wood vs. I’ll Meet You There


Judged by Grace • Find her on Goodreads

So, this was both the hardest and the easiest book battle matchup I have ever judged. It’s going to become obvious fairly quickly which book I chose to advance. For this matchup, I read The Goblin Wood by Hilari Bell (middle grade fantasy) and I’ll Meet You There by Heather Demetrios (young adult contemporary), and the two books could not be more different. I have to admit, I actually knew which book I was advancing after I finished the first book.

The Goblin Wood is a book that is classified as young adult, but it really is more middle grade than anything. It’s a fantasy novel, the story of Makenna, a hedgewitch who witnesses the murder of her mother and flees her village for the forest. There, she allies herself with a goblin, Cogswhallop, and works to get revenge on the humans. She also encounters Tobin, a knight who has fallen from grace by taking on responsibility for his brother’s actions. Tobin has been afforded the opportunity to redeem himself by capturing Makenna. The book explores what happens when Makenna, Cogswhallop, and the goblin army encounter Tobin, and it explores some of the gray areas for each of the characters. It’s the first of a series, and presumably that nuance gets explored in more detail as the story continues.

Middle grade fantasy in general is not a genre that really speaks to me. There’s usually a layer or two of worldbuilding that I find missing from it, and as a result, I tend not to get as drawn into the world. But The Goblin Wood is a good book, albeit I think it’s one I probably would have enjoyed more if I’d read it twenty years ago.

The other book I read for this round, I’ll Meet You There, is a very, very different story. It’s the story of Skylar Evans, who just graduated from high school and wants nothing more than to get out of the small, impoverished town in California where she’s lived all her life. Her father died in a car accident that involved alcohol when Sky was about 12, and since then, it’s just been Sky and her mother. Sky has two best friends: Chris, who loves math and is the only major character of color in the novel, and Dylan, a teen mom. All three of them, along with most of the town, struggle on the verge of poverty. Sky and Dylan both live with their mothers in the trailer park. Chris’s family is much more stable, but it’s alluded to the fact that they have experienced hard times as well. Sky works part-time at the local motel, and one of her coworkers is a young Marine vet, Josh, who was maybe two years ahead of her in school. He’s just returned home after rehab because he was caught in an IED explosion that took his leg and the life of his best friend.

I’ll Meet You There tells the story of Sky’s last summer in her town, Creek View, before she can leave for San Francisco for college, where she plans to study art. Chris and Sky have had a pact for years, where they vowed to avoid romantic entanglements with anyone so that they could focus on school and getting a scholarship so they could get out of town. But when Sky’s mother loses her job at Taco Bell and falls back into bad habits, dating a guy named Billy who is portrayed for most of the novel as pretty worthless and opportunistic, and drinking, everything Sky has worked for seems suddenly impossible. Over the course of the summer, she befriends Josh while working at the motel. Josh used to be the big man in town and is now dealing with major PTSD from his time in the marines and the loss of his legs, and he’s come back to town a very changed young man. Their relationship grows from friendship to something deeper, and they struggle to find a way to be together.

So, here’s where I have to come clean. I hated this book. There’s no way for me to sugar coat it, so I figured I should just put it out there. I didn’t mind it for about the first half of the novel. The prose was pretty solid and while the story wasn’t really grabbing me the way slow burn romances usually do, I didn’t dislike it either. I did have some concerns about how much the book sets itself out as realistic fiction, in that way that it professes to be so realistic in a way that other YA contemporaries aren’t, when I saw things that didn’t feel quite as “real” as they were professed to be. I had concerns about the lack of diversity in the community and among the book’s major characters, and while I understand Josh’s language to be realistic for many boys/young men (he used the terms “faggot” and “homo” and “gay” a decent amount throughout the course of the story), I also have a hard time rooting for those characters.

But ultimately it was the latter half of the novel where everything fell apart for me. Everything in this book is hard, and it’s so hard until the very end, that even if I had liked the ending/resolution of every plot, I don’t think it would have been as uplifting or hopeful as it wanted to be. As it stood, though, I didn’t buy into the plot resolutions and that made everything worse.

Two big threads that weave themselves into the novel are Sky’s budding romance with Josh and the breakdown of Sky’s relationship with her mother. I’ll take them one at a time, starting with Sky and her mother. Mrs. Evans (I cannot for the life of me remember her first name and for that I apologize but I can’t go back to the book for it) has a history of alcohol abuse. She’s been clean for a while now, and they’ve been getting by with Sky’s part time job and Mrs. Evans’ job at Taco Bell. After she loses the job at Taco Bell, though, she falls into a major spiral, takes up with Billy (I think that was his name) who has been sniffing around her for years but she’s never been into before, and starts drinking again. She resists any help from Sky, whether it’s Sky helping her get a job or Sky contacting her sister, to whom she hasn’t spoken since a falling out at her husband’s funeral. Finally, Sky and her mother get into a big fight over everything that’s been going on, and Sky moves out and starts staying at the motel.

The story of Sky and her mother is entwined with Sky’s desire to go to college and escape Creek View: Sky has made all of these plans for college, but with her mother falling apart and the fact that they have no money for rent, bills, or food, Sky simply feels like she can’t leave. At the very end of the summer, Sky’s mother approaches her and reveals that she’s realized she couldn’t stay in Creek View, because then Sky would never leave. So Sky’s mother is going with Billy to Florida, where he’s got a job waiting for him (I think in some kind of auto work, but I can’t remember) that will bring in good money (I feel like I read $2,000 a week, but that might have been for the whole operation and Mrs. Evans and Billy would only get some of it). Mrs. Evans will be the receptionist for that business. This leaves Sky free to go off to college as she’s planned.

The resolution of this plot is ultimately more satisfying than the romance for me, but I still am not buying it. I don’t think this business venture in Florida is very likely to pan out, especially because it’s through Billy, a man who has been portrayed through most of the novel as pretty terrible. Yes, we only see Billy from Sky’s POV, and some of that is tainted because she holds her own alcoholic father up almost as an ideal (which I see, I do, but not to the extent it was shown here). But here’s the thing: in a story where Sky is portrayed as the actual adult, despite the fact that she’s only 18, and where she’s been taking care of her mother and planning and taking on all of the major responsibilities of the household since age 12, Sky not caring for Billy, seeing him as sleezy, and legitimately objecting to the fact that he was a big part of her mother drinking again, should be validated in some way. Or, if that’s not the point, then there needed to be some way of showing Sky, and through Sky the readers, that Billy wasn’t the bad guy she originally thought he was, that his relationship with her mother was genuine, and that there is some substance to him that would lend the Florida business venture a believable option. As it was, all we got was Sky’s mother saying that she felt good when she was with Billy and that she loved him. Well, okay, she probably does think those things, but give me a reason, as a reader, to believe in that feeling of hope you are trying to sell.

And that leaves me with Sky and Josh, and their romance. Slow burn relationships are usually my favorites and I don’t think they’re done enough in YA, but this, I just wasn’t feeling from the beginning. I didn’t hate the relationship at the beginning, but they didn’t have that spark that makes me really root for a pairing and enjoy reading the development of their relationship. The problem was, as the story progressed, I saw more things that either were warning signs to me or are just tropes/situations that I don’t enjoy (there was way too much woman-as-light theme going on here, for example). The party and subsequent near hookup was where the wheels truly came off, though. I don’t enjoy cheating, or near cheating/vague cheating-like scenarios. I especially don’t enjoy it when the innocent party then is humiliated because everyone knows. So while no, Sky and Josh weren’t dating or together in any way officially when this all went down, and I do genuinely feel for Josh and his PTSD (it was the only thing about him I found sympathetic, to be honest), it was going to take a lot to get me to stop actively rooting against them at that point. Demetrios didn’t even come close.

The ending I wanted for Sky was for her to realize that while she’d fallen for Josh over the summer, it was time for her to put this behind her and move on with her life. I would have liked to see him respect her wishes to back off romantically but stay friends. Or, at the very least, I would have liked to see a LOT more from Josh before they even considered the idea of resuming a romantic relationship in the future.

As it stands, this is what I see as the realistic outcome of these stories in the future: Billy’s business fails, and Mrs. Evans is now in Florida, where she knows no one and has no support. She may or may not fall back into drinking. Either way, no good comes of it. And Josh struggles with PTSD, probably isn’t always faithful, probably is drinking when this happens. Dylan may or may not find out. Sky may or may not actually follow through with the “this can’t happen again” promise she made (I lean more towards she doesn’t follow through). More cheesy “how is the Sky today?” lines ensue.

There were other threads of this book (Chris and Dylan, in particular, as well as the woman who owned the motel, who had a son who committed suicide after returning home from the war), but I really can’t touch much on them at this point. All I will say is that for me they were, at the very least, less unsatisfying than the rest of the novel.

This is actually the toned down version of a longer analysis of this story. I know it seems harsh, but I can’t help it. I had a very visceral negative reaction to this book. The parts of it that felt real were, unfortunately, very unsatisfying to me. And for that reason, I knew before I even started reading it, that I would select The Goblin Wood to advance.

Congratulations to The Goblin Wood, which moves on to round 2!


20 thoughts on “Round 1, Match 3: The Goblin Wood vs. I’ll Meet You There

  1. Goblin Wood is shelved in the middle grade section of our library, so I saw it as a middle grade book that should have been written as a YA. Same response, different direction. I really wish it had been more solidly YA, but I liked it anyway.

      1. I’m not posting my review on GR until after my round, since Goblin Wood might end up in my bracket, so I don’t want to go into huge detail, but basically the content is so much more YA–Makenna’s mother’s death, the woman’s miscarriage for examples–that I that I was dissatisfied with how lightly similar issues were touched on. I would have LOVED to see more about the government–I mean, really, this is an invasion story, invasion by outsiders, invasion of their own country by their own government, and a YA version would have been outstanding. And, like Katie says, the characters are YA-aged for most of the book. I had a similar problem with Shield of Stars, which I also felt should have been YA. I really need to read something by Hilari Bell that’s actually a YA book. 🙂

  2. AHHH, I don’t think I realized how bad I’ll Meet You There got for you! I definitely agree with you about Sky’s mom and the boyfriend. I don’t believe that will turn out well at allllll.

    I agree with you on The Goblin Wood, too. It’s not “fair,” but middle grade fantasy seems to often have something missing for me, too. Maybe it’s just the general lack of romance. 😛

    1. I don’t believe that will turn out well at allllll.

      This is just me, and I’m on a bit of a roll with strange readings this battle, but I don’t know that’s it’s supposed to? At least, I didn’t read it as a happily-ever-after, threads-neatly-arranged story. I think she probably is going to mess up, and Billy probably isn’t a great guy, and the whole thing smacked of a get-rich-quick scheme. But I also believed she really didn’t want her daughter taking care of her anymore, and that she wanted to make her own mistakes, and her own life in general.

      I guess I think that about Josh, too. He’ll probably mess up (not that I want him to) but I think he’s still a different guy than he was in high school, and that he did grow up in Afghanistan, and as he heals, he’ll do better. Is that more because I want to believe it? TOTALLY POSSIBLE. But I don’t think that matters 😉

    2. Yeah, I stopped talking about it when I hit the point that it went off the rails because I knew at that point I’d be choosing the Goblin Wood and didn’t want to make it too obvious. I’ve just seen too many similar scenarios with Sky’s mom and the boyfriend to think it could turn out any way but badly. It doesn’t seem like a realistic solution to the issue.

      I know we were talking about this, but middle grade in general just isn’t a genre that does a lot for me outside of a few exceptions and I think it’s just doubly so when I get to MG fantasy…

  3. I have to say, based on the back of the book, I wasn’t really looking forward to potentially reading I’ll Meet You There for the next round. It may not be fair, but your review is essentially confirming my impressions of the book based on the synopsis. Not sure it would have been for me either.

    I’ve just started Goblin Wood, and I’m judging it next round, so I’m not going to say anything now.

        1. Yeah… It emotionally compromised me too, but in the EXACT OPPOSITE of a fun way.

          And I like books like this a lot. I just… didn’t like /this/ book.

    1. I didn’t feel as ecstatic about I’ll Meet you There as most people seemed to, either. I can actually understand where Grace is coming from for a lot of it, I disliked a lot of the same things and since I wasn’t into the romance at all either, it all kind of just felt…meh.

      Soooo not entirely sure, but still pretty convinced you wouldn’t like the book too much either :p

  4. I did have a feeling that I’ll Meet You There wouldn’t be for you, but I didn’t think it would be that bad.

  5. I really liked I’ll Meet You There, but the treatment of Billy really bugged me. We have no evidence that he’s as bad as Skylar thinks except for his bringing her mother alcohol (and even then that’s an assumption Sky makes). Given that we’re expected to believe Josh can go from being an arrogant SOB to being someone decent, I don’t know why Billy has to be an awful person. Not that I believe he’s going to make it big in Florida–that struck me as wishful thinking, $2000 a week–but that could just as easily be overconfidence as being a jerk. So I thought the whole Billy thing was a mistake.

    1. I don’t think we’re expected to believe it, though: I think Demetrios pretty squarely pins it on his year in Afghanistan, and discipline, and Nick, and people around him dying. With Billy, we just see so much less, and we don’t know of anything as drastic in his life. (We’re having a conversation on Billy in two separate places – sorry for the repetition!)

      1. But that’s what I mean by “expected to believe”–she gives us reasons for Josh’s change, and that makes it believable. With Billy, we’re not given anything, which means the only reason to believe he has or hasn’t changed are Sky’s perceptions, and I don’t think those are necessarily valid just because she’s the main character. Why, for instance, does Sky’s mother suddenly decide Billy is a viable romantic prospect? According to Sky, it’s her emotional weakness–but she was emotionally weak after the death of her husband and didn’t give in then, nor did she in the other times between then and the present. Sky never gives her mother credit for any kind of rational decision-making, which is why I think her judgment of Billy is suspect.

        Basically, the ending suggests a couple of possibilities: Billy really has changed, and he and Sky’s mom can make it in Florida; Billy is still a flake and her mom is going to suffer; Billy hasn’t changed, but her mom is now capable of fending for herself. I think the first one is likely, and would see it as a nice parallel to Josh’s transformation. If it’s not true, then Sky’s story is going to end unhappily, because her mother will go back to needing her and will almost certainly drag her away from her freedom. So Billy actually being different would make for a happier ending.

        1. It might have been because she was fired, and she saw Billy as a potential source of stability. I think I read it content with that limited perspective; in general terms, now I’m thinking about POV in general and the degree of omniscience this book has – and it wasn’t omniscient, really, even though it managed to develop a town so clearly. So the lack-of-omniscience or clarity here does stand out (or it does once you pointed it out to me! 🙂 )

          I tend to lean more toward the second option – I’d love for the first to be true but it seems like too much to hope for. I think the third is more likely, especially given the fact that she made up her mind she doesn’t want her daughter taking care of her anymore, but I still don’t think they’re going to strike it rich. Something about Skylar’s perception of Billy makes me think they’re more likely to scrape along. Which is pretty depressing, I guess, but it worked for me anyway: I think it’ll be good for her to get away from the trailer park and the place where her dead husband lived.

  6. Yeah, I’m not reading it (Sorry Beth!). Because I just don’t want to. It is just not a story that appeals to me, on any level.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s